What is Health Sharing?
Health care is a dysfunctional industry. In the United States we spend about 18% of our total GDP on health care, amounting to $6 trillion in annual expenditures. And with the rising costs of in every sector of the health care industry, this poses a substantial financial burden and risk on the individual healthcare consumer. Since 2010, total cost per capita has risen from $8,000 per year to over $16,000 per year. Health insurance premiums have risen 100% substantially outpacing increased wages. Many Americans now find themselves paying high premiums for health insurance plans with high deductibles, limited networks, and bureaucratic battles over prior-authorizations and denials. Health sharing offers a different way.
What is Health Sharing?
In one sentence: health sharing is a free-market based alternative to health insurance. It is a voluntary community of individuals that come together to help one another with their medical bills.
With rising costs, health care poses a significant financial risk for individuals and families. A serious accident, a prolonged hospitalization or a new diagnosis of cancer can result in medical expenses that easily exceed $100,000-$200,000. Even a simple, unexpected surgery can be $20,000 - $80,000. For most, this would result in financial devastation.
As such it is important for individuals to have some mechanism to protect them from financial risk. This is historically where health insurance has filled the gap. Customers pay premiums and cover excluded costs in exchange for a guarantee of payment to physicians or hospitals when services are needed. Unfortunately, the health insurance industry has become so regulated that costs have increased substantially.
This is where health sharing contrasts with insurance. Rather than individuals purchasing a health insurance policy and paying monthly premiums, co-pays, and more, individuals who participate in health sharing become members of a like-minded community. They engage with healthcare providers as self-pay customers. And their monthly health share membership amount is used to help pay or reimburse for each other's eligible medical costs.
How does it work
The next question is, how does this health sharing thing work? One of the key differences, at a practical level is that health share members present to health care providers as self pay patients. This results in several key benefits:
Self paying patients often receive substantial discounts off of insurance rates. This amount varies from provider to provider, but this discount is often in the neighborhood of 35-40% less than the same services billed to insurance.
Self paying patients can shop around for the best deals or the best physicians. Rather than receiving care in an integrated healthcare model where prices may be inflated above market rates, self paying patients can find the places that provide the same services for a lower price. With imaging, for example, the same study may be $1,000 at one location and $500 somewhere else.
Self paying patients are not locked into specific insurance-mandated provider networks. There are no providers that are in network or out of network. As such, they are free to see providers of their own choosing.
When medical expenses happen, the members then submit their invoices to the health sharing organization. If these expenses meet the member guidelines, then the health share reimburses the member for the cost of care. In some cases the health sharing organization can assist the patient with direct to provider payment, but most often, the health share reimburses the members for eligible health care expenses.
How is it different from Insurance
The biggest difference is the legal difference. Health Sharing organizations are non-profit, 501(c)(3) organizations that help members manage their medical expenses. On the other hand, health insurance companies are for-profit organizations that indemnify individuals against risk of health care costs. While that seems like splitting hairs, legally the definitions result in massive differences.
Health insurance is regulated by state insurance law. As such, there is a legal obligation and guarantee that health insurance will pay for covered medical expenses. Now, I know that seems like a very disingenuous statement given the massive number of denials coming from certain health insurance companies and technicalities and gymnastics that they go through in order to exclude certain claims. But legally, there is a requirement to pay.
Health shares on the other hand do not have that legal guarantee to pay. This doesn't mean that health shares leave their members with unfulfilled promises. They are viewed legally as 501(c)(3) charitable organizations. In a number of states they are governed under the state Attorney General rather than the departments covering insurance. That being said, it is in the interest of all health shares to maintain business credibility to maintain their obligations according to their guidelines.
The other big difference between health insurance and health sharing is the rule set governing each entity. Health insurance is a very regulated industry. The 2010 Affordable Care Act (ACA) changed a number of the rules surrounding health insurance. It required a certain set of conditions to be covered by all insurance policies (minimum essential coverage and essential health benefits). It also mandated coverage of pre-existing conditions and guaranteed issue of policies where insurers would previous may not have issued coverage.
The net effect was to dramatically increase the cost of providing insurance policies - to the point that now the average, unsubsidized monthly cost for a family of four in healthcare premiums alone is around $2,500 per month. Government subsidies may bring that down to $600-$800 per month. But families are still left with high deductibles and out of pocket requirements that can reach to $12,000 for individuals and $24,000 for families. This means that the total, unsubsidized, out-of-pocket cost of healthcare per for the average family of 4 can reach as high as $54,000.
Since health shares are not regulated in the way that health insurance is regulated (not subject to mandatory coverage of pre-existing conditions, not required to provide guaranteed issuance, not required to have minimum essential coverage) they are able to provide coverage for important and essential services at a much reduced cost.
Benefits of Health Sharing
Decreased Cost Compared to Insurance: In general, health sharing plans and memberships tend to be less expensive compared with traditional insurance. That is because health sharing operates how insurance ought to run - as a protection against catastrophic medical expenses. Health insurance, though, has become this cumbersome apparatus that pays for every nickel and dime of health care costs and is no longer able to exclude pre-existing conditions. As such, the amount required to manage the financial risk incurred by the insurance companies is significantly greater than for health share organizations.
Alignment of Interests: Compared to health insurance companies, the interests of health sharing organizations are aligned with the members. These are 501(c)(3), non-profit organizations. After operational expenses, all revenue from member contributions are redistributed back in the form of shared medical expenses. Insurance companies on the other hand are often for-profit organizations. Their chief aim is to maximize profit for the shareholder, not the patient.
Freedom: Since health share members are often self-pay patients, they have the freedom to receive care from whatever providers, clinics or hospitals that they choose. They are not necessarily locked into a certain provider network within a certain hospital system or geographic region.






















Comments